Science Without Open Data Isn't Science

Science Without Open Data Isn’t Science

Science Without Open Data Isn’t Science

A new position paper published in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) has generated a lot of controversy among some scientists: Toward Fairness in Data Sharing. It’s not hard to see why: the piece criticizes the concept of data sharing in the context of clinical trials. Data sharing is the much-discussed idea that researchers should make their raw data available to anyone who wants to access it. While the NEJM piece is specifically framed as a rebuttal to this recent pro-data sharing NEJM article, the arguments advanced apply to science more generally.

There is a strong prima facie case that raw scientific data should be made freely available. It is widely recognized that nullius in verba –“on the word of no-one” or “take no-one’s word for it” – is one of the fundamental principles of the scientific endeavor. Scientists do not believe something just because it someone (or even everyone) claims that it is so. Evidence, not opinion, is what science is about.

Read Also:
22 Data Experts Reveal the Top Techniques to Double the Effectiveness of Your Big Data Analysis Efforts

Without open data, a scientific paper is little more than a statement that, in the author’s opinion, some evidence supports a certain set of claims. Without access to the raw data, a reader of a paper has no way of checking whether the results really do support the conclusions of the paper. So, without access to the raw data, the reader is asked to take the results essentially on faith.

It might be said that nullius in verba is an impossible standard.

 



Data Science Congress 2017

5
Jun
2017
Data Science Congress 2017

20% off with code 7wdata_DSC2017

Read Also:
7 Traits a Big Data Scientist Shouldn’t Have

AI Paris

6
Jun
2017
AI Paris

20% off with code AIP17-7WDATA-20

Read Also:
Getting the right people on the big data bus

Chief Data Officer Summit San Francisco

7
Jun
2017
Chief Data Officer Summit San Francisco

$200 off with code DATA200

Read Also:
Top 5 Industrial IoT use cases

Customer Analytics Innovation Summit Chicago

7
Jun
2017
Customer Analytics Innovation Summit Chicago

$200 off with code DATA200

Read Also:
Hybrid infrastructure gets a boost with Big Data
Read Also:
6 Big Data Predictions for 2017

HR & Workforce Analytics Innovation Summit 2017 London

12
Jun
2017
HR & Workforce Analytics Innovation Summit 2017 London

$200 off with code DATA200

Read Also:
Why Deep Learning is Radically Different From Machine Learning

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *